A Mashable Postmortem

Yesterday, I raked Mashable’s Ben Parr for his assertion that Apple’s then yet unannounced mobile advertising platform posed a credible threat to Google. Now that Apple has announced iAd, and seeing how Ben’s rumor reporting was right about it coming, I am circling back for a postmortem. Simply stated: I stand by my assertion that his sourcing was weak and that he didn’t support bold assertions that Apple’s still unreleased mobile ad platform is way ahead Google’s.

Apple CEO Steve Jobs

I was fairly confident that Apple would announce a mobile ad platform today, too, but couldn’t express so yesterday. How would it be when dinging Ben for pushing unsubstantiated rumors that I asserted some myself?

In two Betanews posts, I explain why Apple’s mobile ad platform isn’t way ahead of Google’s—in the way asserted by the Mashable post:

Absolutely, Apple and Google are competing in mobile, but not around advertising platforms (Yet, anyway). I explain how, based on my experience covering the companies as an analyst and journalist, using clear examples. Quickly: Apple’s worldview advocates an app-centric mobile Web where the company tightly controls hardware, software, services and application development platforms. Google’s worldview is a browser-centric mobile Web, built around open-source and open standards. Google’s platform is much more open than Apple’s, but by no means totally.

Ben probably is a hell of a nice guy, and Mashable is one of the blogs I regularly follow. Since I razed his reporting yesterday, I will look for opportunity to praise it in the future.

Do you have a new media or news media story that you’d like told? Please email Joe Wilcox: oddlytogether at gmail dot com.